Two-sided Marketplace: Can it replace the One-sided model?

In recent years, two-sided marketplaces have experienced remarkable growth, significantly impacting various industries. For instance, platforms like Airbnb and Uber have transformed the hospitality and transportation sectors, respectively. According to a Coresight Research report, global revenues from these platforms were projected to double from just below $19 billion in 2017 to over $40 billion by 2022. Furthermore, PricewaterhouseCoopers projected that the global revenue in the sharing economy would reach an incredible $335 billion by 2025.

This impressive growth underscores the immense potential of two-sided marketplaces. But what exactly is a two-sided marketplace, and how does it differ from traditional business models?

First, let's answer the question: What is a Two-sided Marketplace?
A two-sided marketplace is an online platform that connects two distinct user groups—typically buyers and sellers—enabling them to interact and transact directly. Unlike traditional businesses that sell products or services directly to consumers, two-sided marketplaces facilitate exchanges between independent parties, acting as intermediaries.

The key difference between two-sided and one-sided marketplaces lies in their structure and function. In a one-sided marketplace, a business provides goods or services directly to the end customer, maintaining control over the product and the transaction process. In contrast, a two-sided marketplace serves as a platform where two independent user groups can find and engage with each other, with the platform facilitating the interaction but not owning the goods or services exchanged.

Two-sided marketplaces can be categorized into several types:

• Consumer-to-Consumer (C2C): Platforms where individuals sell products or services directly to other individuals. Examples include eBay and Facebook Marketplace.
• Business-to-Consumer (B2C): Marketplaces where businesses offer products or services to consumers. Examples include Amazon Marketplace and Etsy.
• Business-to-Business (B2B): Platforms that facilitate transactions between businesses. An example is Alibaba, connecting manufacturers with retailers.

The two-sided marketplace model offers several strategic advantages that make it one of the most scalable, cost-effective, and innovative business models today. By acting as an intermediary rather than a direct service provider, two-sided marketplaces unlock growth opportunities while minimizing overhead costs.

One of the greatest strengths of a two-sided marketplace is its ability to attract a larger pool of potential customers compared to traditional business models.

• Built-in marketing force: Sellers naturally promote their products/services, bringing in more traffic to the platform.
• Network effect: As more buyers and sellers join, the marketplace’s value increases, creating a self-sustaining growth loop.
• Greater exposure for sellers: Businesses benefit from increased visibility, making the platform a powerful lead generation tool without requiring heavy advertising.

For example, Amazon Marketplace allows businesses to reach millions of customers globally without setting up their own eCommerce infrastructure.

Two-sided marketplaces streamline the process of connecting buyers with sellers, creating a more efficient and convenient experience for both parties.

• Advanced search & algorithms: AI-driven recommendation engines ensure that users find relevant products or services quickly.
• Time savings for buyers: Instead of searching multiple sources, users can find everything in one place.
• Higher conversion rates for sellers: Businesses receive highly targeted leads without needing extensive marketing efforts.

For example, Upwork uses skill-based matching to connect freelancers with businesses looking for specific expertise, increasing efficiency for both sides.

Unlike traditional businesses, which face physical and operational limitations, a two-sided marketplace can scale rapidly by simply onboarding more users.

• No need for inventory management: The marketplace does not own or produce goods, reducing overhead costs.
• Geographic expansion: New regions or product categories can be added without heavy infrastructure investments.
• Attracting premium sellers: As the platform gains credibility, larger brands and service providers join, increasing quality and trust.

Airbnb
Founded in 2008, Airbnb operates as a peer-to-peer platform connecting hosts offering accommodations with travelers seeking lodging. The company generates revenue by charging service fees to both hosts and guests for each booking.
Airbnb continues to expand its offerings beyond traditional short-term rentals. The company is focusing on long-term stays, experiences, and developing new services to enhance user engagement.

Etsy
Launched in 2005, Etsy is an e-commerce platform specializing in handmade, vintage, and unique factory-manufactured items. It connects individual artisans and small businesses with consumers seeking distinctive products. Etsy earns revenue through listing fees, transaction fees, and various seller services.
Etsy has experienced significant growth, with gross merchandise sales reaching $13.2 billion in 2023. The platform continues to expand its user base, boasting 7 million sellers and 92 million buyers as of December 2022.

The answer is No, two-sided marketplaces cannot completely replace one-sided marketplaces, as both models serve different purposes in the digital economy.
Two-sided marketplaces, such as Airbnb, Uber, and Etsy, have gained popularity due to network effects and scalability, allowing them to grow rapidly by connecting buyers and sellers without owning inventory or directly providing services. This model is highly effective for industries where efficient matchmaking between two independent user groups is essential.
However, one-sided marketplaces continue to play a crucial role in various sectors. These platforms operate by selling products or services directly to consumers without relying on third-party sellers. Examples include Apple’s App Store and Netflix, which control their content and services, ensuring a consistent experience and quality. Additionally, industries with strict regulations or exclusive offerings, such as digital media platforms, software distribution, and niche e-commerce sites, often benefit from a one-sided model.
While two-sided marketplaces dominate many sectors, they cannot completely replace one-sided marketplaces, as each model serves different business needs. Instead of one replacing the other, both models coexist, catering to different industries and customer demands.

If you're looking to build, optimize, or scale a two-sided marketplace, Journeyhorizon is your trusted partner. As an industry-leading expert in marketplace development, we provide end-to-end solutions—from concept and design to full-scale growth strategies.
With deep expertise in platform development, user acquisition, monetization strategies, and scaling marketplaces, Journeyhorizon helps businesses turn marketplace ideas into thriving, high-growth platforms.
🚀 Ready to build your own marketplace? Let Journeyhorizon help you create a scalable, secure, and successful two-sided platform that stands out in today’s competitive digital landscape. Contact us today to get started!